Insights & advice

Surveyors must pay compensation for negligent valuation

Negligent Valuation Surveyors Pay Compensation | Middletons Solicitors | Andover Solicitors 

A firm of surveyors has been ordered to pay compensation to a finance company for negligently providing a property valuation that was far too high.

The case arose after the surveyors valued a house at £3.4m in July 2007. On the basis of that valuation the finance company provided the purchaser with a loan of £250,000 by way of a second mortgage. The purchaser later got into financial difficulties and the property was repossessed and sold for £2m.

The property had been subject to a first charge in respect of the first mortgage and so the finance company didn’t recover any of its losses.

The court held that the surveyors owed a duty of care to carry out the valuation to the standard of a reasonable valuer of ordinary competence and experience.

The correct valuation of the property at that time was £2.8m with a 10% range either way. The surveyors’ valuation report and accompanying notes had not explained how they had arrived at a figure of £3.4m. It was a valuation which no reasonable valuer could have suggested.

The surveyors had been negligent because they had failed to approach the valuation process in the right way. The finance company had relied on the valuation when making the loan and was entitled to be compensated for its losses.

Please contact Ingrid Hindle or Jo Ayrton in our Warminster office on 01985 214444 or email or for more information about the issues raised in this article.

We provide client focussed legal advice and assistance.

Our solicitors strive to deliver the best advice and assistance and an outstanding customer experience.

We serve our customers right the way across Wiltshire and Hampshire with offices in Warminster, Amesbury and Stockbridge.

Enquire about our services today.

Just a short note to once again express my sincere thanks to you, Sue and the M&U team, for all your help, cooperation and first class professional support. I am most grateful to you all.

Chris Stephenson, Warminster

Middletons Solicitors uses cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue we assume that you consent to receive all cookies on this website.