We wish to inform our clients that our Andover office is now closed. Please call our Amesbury office on 01980 883 100 for document retrieval and to book appointments.

Insights & advice

Engineering firm wins court battle over unpaid invoices

Engineering Firm Wins Unpaid Invoices Legal Battle | Middletons Solicitors | Andover Solicitors 

A British engineering firm has won its legal battle with a French company that refused to pay its invoices after claiming the goods supplied were unfit for purpose.

The issue arose when the French firm complained that the various pieces of engineering machinery did not have certificates of conformity which are necessary under an EU directive. It said this meant they could not be sold and so were unfit for purpose under the Sale of Goods Act 1979.

This was in spite of the fact that it had actually sold each piece of equipment to its own customers both in and outside the European Union.

The court held that the machines clearly were fit for purpose as the French firm had been able to sell them in different European countries.

The Court of Appeal has now upheld that decision. It said there was no evidence that the EU Directive had been brought into effect in the member states where the French firm was trading. On that basis, the claim that the goods were unsalable could not succeed.

Please contact us in our Warminster office on 01985 214444 or Westbury on 01373 865577  if you would like more information about the issues raised in this article or any aspect of contract law.


We provide client focussed legal advice and assistance.

Our solicitors strive to deliver the best advice and assistance and an outstanding customer experience.

We serve our customers right the way across Wiltshire and Hampshire with offices in Warminster, Amesbury and Stockbridge.

Enquire about our services today.

Just a short note to once again express my sincere thanks to you, Sue and the M&U team, for all your help, cooperation and first class professional support. I am most grateful to you all.

Chris Stephenson, Warminster

Middletons Solicitors uses cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue we assume that you consent to receive all cookies on this website.